Spiga

Shakira Rocks, Beyonce Flops

February 28, 07 by Ballz!

Beyonce and Shakira

Shakira shows Beyonce how it’s a done in a new collaborative track “Beautiful Liar.” Looking very much alike from the dance moves to the wild hair, Beyonce comes off as a poor version of Shakira, but hats off to the girl for once wanting to share the spotlight with someone other than Jay-Z!

[youtube ZtVnUXOLQ0k]

“Beautiful Liar,” will appear on an upcoming re-issue of Beyonce’s ‘’B’day.’’ The new version reportedly comes with a new twist: 6 songs in Spanish, which, Shakira humbly praised her for.

“(Beyonce) has a very good accent when she sings in Spanish and I think anything that she wants to do she will do just fine, because she is a very determined and focused woman and that is something to admire. She is a great artist” says the hip swirling queen.

Beyonce and Shakira-2Beyonce and Shakira



Add your comment

55 responses for this post

  1. JESSICA Says: 01.03.07 at 3:22 pm

    THIS VIDEO LOOKS LIKE IT CAME STRAIGHT OUT OF THE 80s

  2. Gin Says: 01.03.07 at 4:19 pm

    My thought exactly! It’s hot a video though with two of music’s hottest hip-shakers. I guess more videos need to be like this. Back in the 80’s and the 90’s people focused more on their music and singing rather than the latest fashion trends, stripping and the most expensive videos. I’m so sick of today’s colourful videos with women portrayed as skanky strippers! Kudos to Beyonce and Shakira. Hot but yet classy :)

  3. Victoria Says: 05.03.07 at 12:00 am

    I think the song is terrible and the video was obviously cheaply produced. Both thumbs down.

  4. Mike Smith Says: 13.03.07 at 8:07 pm

    I believe beyonce showed shakira how it is done down south adding a little stlye and humph but the video is beautiful with them together

  5. hellen Says: 22.03.07 at 4:06 pm

    i think beyonce did an excellent performance with shakira.and yes shakira is more bendy and flexier than beyonce but atleast she did as best she can.i loved beyonce performance.
    shakira was the same i loved both performances.

    lots of love hellen.

  6. Me Says: 23.03.07 at 6:37 pm

    Although she looks hot belly dancing, Beyonce seems to be trying too hard. I think she asked Shakira to do this song/video with her so that she could show everyone that she can belly dance too, which she can but not better than Shaki (in my opinion anyway). This way, Beyonce can get away with making a music video of her belly dancing without people saying she’s just trying to be like Shakira.

  7. ya boi Says: 24.03.07 at 9:23 pm

    first of all whoeva me is u dont know what the hell u talkin bout beyonce is hot as a motha fatha. i bet yo ass dont know how to belly dance so before you criticize her u try to belly dance and take some classes for yourself.and for the one who said that shakira does it better beyonce does it betta hands down - word 2 everything. and also for the record shakira sounds like a damn man.wit out beyonce that song wouldnt be nuthin but dirt.

  8. Me Says: 25.03.07 at 10:23 pm

    Who’s criticizing? Not ME. I merely gave an opinion. If you don’t like it, too bad. Get over it.

  9. bora Says: 27.03.07 at 6:14 am

    Moderators note: Thank you for your comment Bora, but only comments in English will be accepted, I’m afraid.

  10. ceylan Says: 29.03.07 at 10:12 pm

    i think beyonce dance the best shakira is good to but beyonce her performens is unbeliveble

  11. her Says: 17.07.07 at 8:32 pm

    i think that shakira is the best at belly dancing than any other chick, even beyonce. shakira has the curves, flexibility and beyonce has the boottie and that helps beyonce look like she is belly dancing. shaki has been b.d (belly dancing) all of her life so obviousely shaki is way better. NO DOUBT!!!

  12. her Says: 17.07.07 at 8:34 pm

    oh and by the way if shaki wasnt in this video it would be nothing. but still i think that the video is awesome!!!

  13. titi Says: 23.07.07 at 11:27 am

    shakira mailove

  14. anita Says: 29.07.07 at 11:25 am

    love 2

  15. hina Says: 29.07.07 at 5:16 pm

    i luv dis song so much, dis song is teh best,

  16. sidney Says: 29.07.07 at 9:36 pm

    ok i think that beyonce tried waaaaay 2 hard in this video and it showed (in a nongood way) but shakira is a natural u can totally tell the song is amazing too but i just dont think they should have both belly danced cuz watching beyonce try 2 belly dance is stinging my eyes

  17. j Says: 30.07.07 at 3:07 pm

    yo shakira looked fine and B looked fine. they both beautiful women and they’r both great dancers. so who givs a dam if one person thinks its bad and another thinks is good. thas a persons opinion.respect it. it dont realy matter cuz guess who got that $$$ in the end.
    besides that video nd song mad old anywyz.
    peace

  18. Courtney Says: 31.07.07 at 9:47 pm

    I think there both fantastic, they both have there own thing goin on and there dancing is quiet diffrent… i think beyonce can move her ass lik no other but shakira has the moves … they are both beautiful women xXx

  19. darkangel Says: 01.08.07 at 8:49 pm

    i think they both did good!!! shaira is more experienced in belly dancing,, but beyonce is a good performer and singer + dancer

    but beyonce can try to do any dance she can!!!

  20. di Says: 02.08.07 at 9:38 am

    i think beyonce is forcing herself tooo much to b able 2 bely dance like shakira!!!!the last part is AWFUL 4 beyonce!!!!

  21. hustler Says: 02.08.07 at 12:37 pm

    i hope i could f**k shakira’s ass

  22. BLA Says: 02.08.07 at 10:12 pm

    They’re both good dancers… Shakira (a natural)… Beyonce (tried to be better than Shakira) … notice they had use shakira’s belly dancing on both her n beyonce.. on the hook…… watch the video the part they’re putting their hair up.. it’s only shakira really doing it, just proves Beyonce couldn’t do it better than her and she didn’t wanna look bad so shakira did it 4 both of them. Beyonce can dance ANYTHING but she just can’t top off Shakira’s belly dancing. N yea the last part was was where Beyonce did look bad (she was trying TOOO hard) It’s still one of my fav. videos

  23. REBEKAH Says: 03.08.07 at 7:07 am

    I THINK SHAKIRA WAS NATURAL AND MUCH MORE BETTER IN DOING THE DANCING PART, BUT I THINK THE VIDEO WAS AWESOME……

  24. fizz Says: 03.08.07 at 5:24 pm

    stop hatin on beyonce
    she can do her own thing
    and dats all dat matter
    so ussh u fuked up ppl
    and dnt bother 2 holla bak at me fools

  25. DeViL Says: 04.08.07 at 1:38 am

    i think beyonce is trying to do the belly dance but without shakira is the video just a pece off shitt what eva some things totally difrind bye bye peace

  26. rogelyn asuncion Says: 06.08.07 at 10:21 am

    hi!nd hello

  27. cutesxynss Says: 06.08.07 at 5:48 pm

    u noe wat beyonce and shakira are very beautiful and sexii women and this video provess how much dey look alike which mean nobody is betta than nobody even though shakira can belly dance better beyonce can shake her ass more dis aint about whos betta dey both are and ya need 2 shut up cuz it sounds like ya jus bein racist ( am latina and i still vote 4 both soo dont get it twisted)

  28. Dawood Ahmed Says: 07.08.07 at 6:34 pm

    Shakiraaaa Iz A Fukinn Bad Ass Dancer!! =D
    Butt Ma Baybi Gurl Can Do Betterrr ( I Fink) =p..Belly Dancing Rockz..Look Well Bum!! 2 Sexy Laydee’z *Shamila* *Shakira*

  29. Fredy Says: 07.08.07 at 11:43 pm

    Beyonce it`s very sexy, a woman that will be history in the music would, but Shakira also, like the winner. Do you see Beyonce Experience with bellydance? Good, but nothing like SHAKIRA. And Shaky is very beautiful and we dream with her movement near our eyes.

  30. sanja Says: 10.08.07 at 12:19 am

    shakira is better than b. beyonce doesn’t know how to dance!

  31. . Says: 10.08.07 at 2:58 pm

    I think that we speak very very about of the hips of Shakira, a dance don’t is only hips, too are other parts of the body of a person, but it’s my comment.
    Also was obvious that Shakira move the hips and this don’t was surprise.

  32. denise/girley Says: 10.08.07 at 3:59 pm

    beyonce is a leader and shakira is a follower and i love beyonce so much i would love to be her and i dont want to be shakira because she is a ugly and a hot mess but my home girl beyonce is the best and prettyest and all i got to say is beyonce you lok fab even if u fell down the staires u look wonderful

  33. fernanda Says: 11.08.07 at 1:47 am

    shakira eres la mejor del mundo

  34. fjolla Says: 12.08.07 at 4:27 pm

    beyonce je e beautiful

  35. dee Says: 12.08.07 at 9:48 pm

    I think shakiras pretty good at dancing but shes not all of that, if you know what i mean.. everyones like omg look shakira shakita…she can belly dance!! Yes she is talented but i think Beyonce did a pretty good job ….i mean she was really good for like someone whove never done anything like that before….anyways… and yeah btw i know a lot of girls who could belly dance better than shakira…and i know i can, ive been like belly dancing for as long as i remember..Shakira btw have been dancing since she was like 3…and shes like 23 or something,…i mean im just 18.

    And yeah,..youre all like saying that beyonce’s so bad at belly dancing,..you think any of you guys could do a better job..(i dont think so)

    thats all! bye!

  36. Trisha Says: 13.08.07 at 11:00 am

    Hon, before you run your mouth off on Shakira at least get some of your facts straight. She is not 23, but 30. Yes, I know she looks refreshingly young compare to Beyonce who looks like a hag and a bag at the side of her and so it’s easy to mistake her for a younger woman. It’s funny how you put Shakira down for her belly dancing, and at the same time put yourself up. You maybe a good belly dancer, but Shakira is so much more than that. Not only does she have a way about her dancing that no one else has, but she’s got ”IT”. The looks, the charm and the attitude to top it all. Beyonce did do a good job of looking like a poor version of Shakira, and you’re right not many could do a better job. You know why? Coz not many have the money to throw on the worlds most top most choreographers!

  37. Chags Says: 13.08.07 at 12:23 pm

    B was great great song and video both did well but props to B

  38. Victoria Says: 14.08.07 at 7:43 pm

    hey Beyonce is so much perttier than shakira and shakira really needs to go to the beach and get a tan really bad….laters bithches and hoes

  39. Gem Says: 17.08.07 at 3:16 pm

    i thought they were both sexy and shakira is just……BAMMM!

  40. Yaaa Says: 20.08.07 at 3:04 am

    It will be amazing to see both of them in a sex movie with some lesbian action…damn … so hot

  41. DaredeVil Says: 25.08.07 at 12:55 pm

    I don’t think Shakira has any rival at belly dancing Beyonce even though beautiful also still needs much practice in order to meet up with Shakira.

  42. dont worry Says: 27.08.07 at 3:02 am

    Beyonce copies everyone, it’ll never change, she copied aaliyah’s dance with the belly roll going down with it, she copied the back bend from ciara, and now she copin shakira dance, she coped Amerie’s sound, who’s next? the thing is that beyonse is tryna claim other pplz dance move like she da shit, my body is sicker than hers and if I was a better singer than her I would be over her, cuz I can dance like crazy and their my own dance moves.

  43. yaidel Says: 12.09.07 at 6:49 am

    beyonce no copia a shakira sino que baila en su terreno y no hace muy bien ahora dile a shakira que haga un buen video con bailes distintos a ese que esta gastadisimo ya he perdido la cuenta de cuantos videos suyos tienen los mismos pasos y dile que aprenda a bailar como beyonce y saque un video al estilo de beyonce haber si va poder acercarse a como baila beyonce
    SHAKIRA NO SABE BAILAR MAS NADA APARTE DE LA DANZA DEL VIENTRE Y LO DEMUESTRA EN TODOS SUS VIDEOS

  44. Antonio Says: 12.09.07 at 12:42 pm

    Aquí nadie opina bien en español? Q idioma hablan? xD

  45. georgina Says: 15.09.07 at 8:53 pm

    yo pienso que shakira es la mejor cantante del mundo;una observacion entre shakira y beyonce es que se parece mucho a shakira pero en lo fisico.

  46. Carina França Says: 25.09.07 at 4:03 pm

    XXiii… Precisa treinar um pouco o portugues eim!!!

  47. alx Says: 04.10.07 at 2:58 pm

    shakira es mejora baillarina y mejora cantante.. ella esta muy bonita..(shakira is a better dancer and singer.. she is very cute)
    beyonce no es muy buena cantante pero esta bonita(beyonce isn’t a good singer but she is preety too)

  48. lucho Says: 12.10.07 at 10:37 pm

    shakira estas re buena como me gustaria conoserte para partirte como un queso te rompo en 100000 pedasos yeguaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

  49. funktup Says: 24.10.07 at 7:56 am

    the last 5 seconds of the video r the best! that’s where beyonce shows whose boss…

  50. amrit Says: 28.10.07 at 10:14 am

    i love u dear its fine dance in india i m dieing fane of u , so repie of me dear shakhira

  51. FAHAD Says: 05.11.07 at 6:39 pm

    I love shakhira & Britney Spears

    Please send electronic images S** and s** movies Britney Spears & shakhira TO AL_FAHAD_15@HOTMAIL.COM

    Thank you very much

  52. LYDIA BROWN Says: 26.01.08 at 10:03 pm

    BEYONCE IS A SPOILT INSECURE AND SELFISH BRAT WHO BELIEVES THAT SHE’S INVINCIBLE SO SHE CONTINUOUSLY HAS TO PUT UP AN UNDERCOVER FIGHT WITH HER CONTENDERS BUT I SAW IT IN THE STARS THAT STORM FERDINA IS COMING HER WAY SOON.AUW!

  53. mitchel bellmerth Says: 07.05.08 at 9:02 pm

    le duela a quien le duela shakira es la mejor lista de records!! recorrio el mundo con sus dos tours,,tiene mas de secenta millonesssssss de discos vendidos ,estubo cantando en la fifa,, tiene el recor de mexico con 215 mil personas en concierto,,le quito el record a gwen stefani de la cancion mas sonade de la radio de usa con hips dont lie y esta misma cancion #one en el internet ,, juan pablo 2do la resibio en el baticano nice y asta los presidentes la resiben y cada vez que va a llegar a un pais 2 weeks antes ponen sus videos y conciertos en la tv de echo en mexico la resiben mucho mejor que a paulina y thalia y es la 4ta mujer mas rica del esp y la unica latina y tiene un corazon autuista y en el continentes autraliano,asiatico y africano es la mejor cantate de la musica en ingles para los chundos que no sabian baila como nadie lo ase auque le quieran copiar compone musica y escribe sus canciones eres unica sheki por que eres grande en un pais muy dificil y beyonce que es

  54. mitchel bellmerth Says: 07.05.08 at 9:07 pm

    fans de shakira escribanme mebarakfirst@gmail.com

  55. Kyle Says: 01.06.08 at 12:30 am

    Well, actually, no. The people that Beyoncé only did the video to show off her belly-dancing moves are wrong. In fact, Shakira was the one that taught Beyoncé to belly-dance for the video.

Leave a Reply